Album of the Week 48-2023: Peter Gabriel – i/o
While it doesn’t quite have the reputation that ‘Chinese Democracy’ or ‘Black Messiah’ had, ‘i/o’ has been about twenty years in the making. It probably helps that Peter Gabriel had been on tour and releasing things in the intervening years, but ‘i/o’ was originally slated for release as early as 2004. Since Gabriel is known for making carefully crafted, multi-layered albums to begin with, the lengthy process hasn’t hurt the album nearly as much as it would have if a more conventional rock band would have done something similar. In fact, ‘i/o’ is everything one would want from a Peter Gabriel album.
Given the lengthy conception of the album, it is quite remarkable that ‘i/o’ sounds like a fairly logical continuation of 2002’s ‘Up’. Some of the songs were written around the same time, and it shows. ‘i/o’ is full of the clever songwriting that comes from the grey area between art pop and art rock Gabriel is known for. The world music influences are there, but they are a bit more subtle. Gabriel and his musicians – some of which he has been working with for over four decades – alternate between songs that feel like they were written for a live band and more electronically enhanced studio-based arrangements.
Interestingly, as dense and well thought-out as the arrangements are, the songs on ‘i/o’ are fairly memorable and accessible. Gabriel does throw the odd curveball at the listener, such as the sparse prog-funk of ‘The Court’ or the eighties new wave extravaganza of ‘Road to Joy’, but even those are very listenable. The majority of the album consists of very introspective, yet emotionally intense ballads, catchy alternative pop and songs with subtle washes of synthesizers enhanced by Gabriel’s voice and varying degrees of electronic percussion. And because Gabriel’s sense of musical direction is so strong, it all works.
One thing that does bug me about ‘i/o’ is that it is offered in two different mixes: the clean and open “Bright-Side Mix” and the more hazy, bottom-heavy “Dark-Side Mix”. It reeks of an indecisiveness that an album so long in the making should not have. Especially because most of the tracks have one specific mix that clearly is the more appropriate one. The low-key ballads and more electronics-oriented songs like ‘Love Can Heal’, ‘And Still’ and ‘So Much’ profit from the darker mix, while the more accessible live drums-oriented material like ‘Olive Tree’ sounds best with a brighter mix.
Despite all that, ‘i/o’ is much better than I expected it would be. At age 73, Gabriel’s warm voice is still as good as ever and the songwriting is excellent. Those who have followed Peter Gabriel throughout his career will have no trouble adjusting to ‘i/o’. Anyone who mainly knows him from the hits on ‘So’ might need some time due to nothing being as immediate as the likes of ‘Sledgehammer’ or ‘Red Rain’, but even then, you might fall for the album. Seeing as it took him so long to make the album, ‘i/o’ might just be Gabriel’s final original work, but it’s one to be proud of.
Recommended tracks: ‘Love Can Heal’, ‘The Court’, ‘Panopticom’, ‘So Much’